Looked at from the
point of view of unemployment, the US reflects a phase of near continuous
buoyancy with declining employment rates (from 7.5 to 4.2 per cent)
starting in 1992, but Japan has recorded a continuous increase in
unemployment rates from 2.1 to 4.2 per cent between 1991 and 1999,
Germany from around 6 to over 9 per cent and France from 9 to 11-12
per cent (Chart 3). Thus within the developed "triad", the good days
seem to be large confined to the workers in the US, and to
an extent in the UK.
Chart 3 >>
Further, there are
signs of an increase in instability both in the financial and the
real realms of the world economy. The instability in the financial
sector, noted at the beginning of this article, has been widely reported
by the media. But in the real realm too, besides the two phases of
significant slowdown in economic growth (in 1991-93 and 1998-99) over
the decade, and the crises in Mexico, East Asia, Russia and Brazil,
the 1990s have closed with extreme weakness in Japan, despite repeated
efforts to revive the economy with lower interest rates and large
deficits. Figures reported in April this year suggest that restructuring
efforts by Japanese firms have not merely kept unemployment at its
post-War high of 4.9 per cent, but unemployment among males rose by
0.1 percentage point that month to touch 5.2 per cent and that unemployment
among males aged 15-24 rose by 0.8 per cent year-on-year to touch
a record 12.5 per cent.
This combination of
slower growth, greater divergence in growth and increasing instability,
stems precisely from the growing role of finance in the international
system. There are a number of features of this rise to dominance of
finance, which have been noted earlier in these columns. Despite talk
of a new architecture, the global financial system remains highly
centralised, with a few US financial institutions intermediating global
capital flows. Decisions by a few agents determine the "exposure"
of the system, which appeared to work well, till reports of the near
collapse of Long Term Capital Management came in. The Soros development
indicates that was not an isolated instance. The adverse role of individual
decision-making is illustrated here as well. As Stanley Druckenmiller,
a senior executive at Quantum Fund reportedly put it: "I screwed
up. I should have got out in February
This business is a bit
like a drug. When you are doing well its hard to quit.". Unfortunately,
unregulated entities run by intoxicated individuals making highly
speculative investments are at the core of the system.
Further, with financial
firms betting on interest rate differentials and exchange rate changes
at virtually the same time, the various asset markets relating to
debt, securities and currency are increasingly integrated. Developments
in any one of these markets affect the others as well. It is in this
light that the trends in interest rates have to be assessed. As Chart
4, which provides the trends in short term interest rates suggest,
since the early 1990s, interest rates in the US have risen, while
those in Germany and Japan have fallen. This has meant that the interest
rate parity between the US, Japan and Germany in 1990, has given way
to a situation where US interest rates rule much higher than in the
other two countries, the gap is in fact tending to widen. Since inflation
rates (Chart 5) in the US have tended to converge, while those in
Japan have fallen, the real interest rate differential has widened
even further.
Chart 4 >>
chart 5 >> |